original song · night herd

That's Why the Old Songs Run Sad

Country · old-time · melancholic, mournful

▶ Play That's Why the Old Songs Run Sad

A kid asks the oldest question there is about cowboy songs, and gets an answer he does not understand until a letter reaches him three weeks above the Cimarron. No case behind this one — but the practice it is built on is real, and well recorded.

The story behind the song

Cowboys on a trail drive really did sing to the cattle, and not for their own entertainment. The fullest first-hand account is Texas Jack’s, published in The Spirit of the Times in 1876. Two men rode the night watch at a time, “ridin’ round and round them in opposite directions.” The singing, he wrote, “seems to soothe the fears of the cattle” — it covered sudden noises, kept predators off, and told the herd where the riders were. If the singing stopped, Texas Jack said, that “would, in all probability, be the signal for a general stampede.”

That is where the song’s whole premise comes from. The music was work, it was sung by a man alone in the dark to an animal that could not judge it, and it was often improvised on the spot. That is an almost perfect recipe for the kind of song a person sings when nobody is listening — which is what the chorus is arguing: “You don’t need much of a tune out here, just one the herd has had.”

The geography is of a piece with it. San Antonio to Kansas is the shape of the Texas drives; the Cimarron is a real crossing on the way north, three weeks out being about right for a herd making ten or twelve miles a day. Point is the position at the head of the moving herd and drag is the back, where the slowest cattle and the dust are — so a voice carrying from the drag “clear up where I rode point” is the length of the whole herd. That is the distance the last verse is measuring.

What the record says, and what the song adds

There is no case here and no real people. The kid from San Antone, Old Jim, the Waco girl and the letter are invented; nobody’s brother died. What is not invented is the job: two men, the dark, the herd, and singing because stopping was dangerous.

One detail sits slightly off the record. Texas Jack describes watches of two hours; the song has “ten till two,” which is four. Watch lengths varied between outfits and the song is not wrong to use a longer trick — but if you want the number that is actually documented, it is two.

Sources

Lyrics

A kid come up from San Antone, His first drive with the crew, He drawed the second watch with me And didn't know what to do. We rode the herd from ten till two, The cattle bedded bad, He said, "How come a cowboy's song Is nearly always sad?" I said, "You've still got town on you, Wait till you've rode a spell. Wait till Texas is a month behind And Kansas hard to tell. When every man you've talked to Is the same six hands around, You'll sing about the folks you miss When there's no folks to be found." That's why the old songs run sad, son, They've got a ways to ride. A fellow sings what's on his mind When there's no one at his side. You don't need much of a tune out here, Just one the herd has had — Ride her slow and sing her low, That's why the old songs run sad. Old Jim sang of a Waco girl Who'd said that she would wait. She married while he rode up north; The letter found him late. He read it once at breakfast, Folded it and put it by, Then sang the same old courting song On night herd by and by. Three weeks above the Cimarron The kid quit asking why. A letter caught us at the creek; His oldest brother'd died. That night I heard him on the drag Clear up where I rode point, A thin young voice, a song I'd never heard, And the tune all out of joint. That's why the old songs run sad, son, They've got a ways to ride. A fellow sings what's on his mind When there's no one at his side. You don't need much of a tune out here, Just one the herd has had — Ride her slow and sing her low, That's why the old songs run sad. He didn't sing it very pretty. Didn't matter if he had. The cattle all lay quiet, And the song ran sad.

Lyrics by David van Coolwijk. Sung with an AI voice model based on his own voice; the music is made with AI (Suno). Printed here as written, without the production notes that appear in the player’s lyric sheet.

Credits

Lyrics
David van Coolwijk (captainfrasca)
Vocal
AI voice model based on David’s own voice
Music
Made with AI (Suno); the melody is sometimes David’s own
In the catalogue
Country · old-time · melancholic, mournful
Rights status
© David van Coolwijk / Boot Scoot Media. All rights reserved.

Or start a full listening session →

The other songs in this group