original song · Gentry County, Missouri, 1858

Remember Fifty-Eight

Murder Song · murder-ballad · mournful, bitter

▶ Play Remember Fifty-Eight

A footnote in a county history, one sentence long, opened out into a ballad. This page has to be straight with you about how much of it is that sentence and how much of it is the song.

The story behind the song

The documented part is short enough to quote whole. A township history of Gentry County, Missouri says, of a farm in the north-western part of Bogle Township where Wright Stevens had a grist mill: “About 1858, on the same farm, a man by the name of Timmons was waylaid, shot and killed by Milligan and Kestler.”

That is the whole of it. No first names. No date beyond “about 1858.” The second name spelled Kestler, not Kessler. And — worth noticing — in that one sentence the two men are the killers, plainly, with no warrant and no doubt in it.

What the record says, and what the song adds

Everything else in the song is the song. The warrant, the old quarrel, the wife out searching the fields near midnight, the crowd taking Kestler from the courthouse past the sheriff, the old elm, the bedcord that parted and was knotted and used again, Milligan’s ten days of running and his asking for baptism — none of that is in the sentence above, and no other source reachable here confirms any of it. If a record of a lynching in Gentry County in 1858 exists, it is not one that has been seen for this page. The chorus counts three dead where the record names one; that is the song’s arithmetic, not the county’s.

Which is, to be fair, exactly what ballads have always done with a line in a county book: take the one sentence that survived and supply the night around it. It is only dishonest if nobody says so. If you know this part of Gentry County, or have the local histories to hand, corrections are welcome.

Sources

Lyrics

Come all ye men of Gentry County And listen while I tell Of Bogle Township, fifty-eight, And how three men there fell. A warrant came for Samuel Timmons And Kessler served it out, With young James Milligan beside him Across the farming ground. Now Kessler and Sam Timmons Had quarreled times before, So Timmons kept about his land And stayed away from the door. What passed between those two men No living tongue can say, But folks said Samuel took the buckshot With his back turned away. Oh, Bogle Township, mind that summer, Remember fifty-eight. One man fell upon his own ground And two more met their fate. Near midnight Samuel's wife went out And searched the fields alone. She found her husband where he'd fallen On the ground he called his own. The neighbors gathered, anger rose, And word went through the town That Kessler would be brought to answer Before the sun went down. They took him from the courthouse Though the sheriff barred the way, And led him to an old elm tree Before the close of day. They hauled him up, the bedcord parted, And Kessler struck the ground. They tied the broken rope together And hauled him up again. Young Milligan made his escape, But not for very long. Ten days later men came back And fetched him back with the throng. He asked for Christian baptism Before they led him on, Then from the limb that carried Kessler Young Milligan was gone. Oh, Bogle Township, mind that summer, Remember fifty-eight. Samuel Timmons died by gunshot And two more met their fate. The warrant lay, the judge still sat, The courthouse doors stood wide, But three men lay in Gentry County Before that summer died. Remember fifty-eight.

Lyrics by David van Coolwijk. Sung with an AI voice model based on his own voice; the music is made with AI (Suno). Printed here as written, without the production notes that appear in the player’s lyric sheet.

Credits

Lyrics
David van Coolwijk (captainfrasca)
Vocal
AI voice model based on David’s own voice
Music
Made with AI (Suno); the melody is sometimes David’s own
In the catalogue
Murder Song · murder-ballad · mournful, bitter
Rights status
© David van Coolwijk / Boot Scoot Media. All rights reserved.

Or start a full listening session →

The other songs in this group