A warning ballad with the warning turned inward. The poison in it is the grudge, not the arsenic — “for poison first is swallowed long before it meets the cup.”
The story behind the song
On 25 May 1853, in Troy, New York, Henrietta Robinson sat down at the table of the grocer Timothy Lanagan, called for beer, and asked Lanagan’s wife to fetch sugar. Lanagan drank, and so did the Lanagans’ boarder, Catherine Lubee. Both fell ill about two hours later, and both were dead within the day, of arsenic poisoning.
She had bought arsenic from a Troy druggist on 10 May — the “some fifteen days before” of the song, which is exactly right. A search of her house turned up arsenic hidden under a carpet.
Her capital trial was heard in May 1854 at the Court of Oyer and Terminer in Rensselaer County, Judge Ira Harris presiding. She kept her veil down in court. Harris ordered her to raise it; she lifted it only briefly and then hid behind a fan. The press called her the Veiled Murderess and the name stuck. Her counsel argued insanity. The jury convicted her and she was sentenced to death; the Governor commuted it to life. She spent the rest of it at the state hospital for the insane at Matteawan, and died there on 14 May 1905, aged 89.
What the record says, and what the song adds
The one thing nobody ever got out of her was who she was. All that is known of her past is that she arrived in Troy in 1850, moved to Albany in 1851, and came back to Troy to live across from the Lanagans’ store. The motive is the same blank: the song’s “some bitter words” is about as close as the record gets, which is why the chorus ends up being about spite in general rather than about her. The scene in the courtroom needs no invention — the veil, the order to raise it, the fan, the twelve men — it is in the case file as written.
Sources
- People v. Robinson, 1854 — Historical Society of the New York Courts
- Henrietta Robinson — Women in History and the Law, William & Mary Law School
Lyrics
Lyrics by David van Coolwijk. Sung with an AI voice model based on his own voice; the music is made with AI (Suno). Printed here as written, without the production notes that appear in the player’s lyric sheet.
Credits
- Lyrics
- David van Coolwijk (captainfrasca)
- Vocal
- AI voice model based on David’s own voice
- Music
- Made with AI (Suno); the melody is sometimes David’s own
- In the catalogue
- Country · murder-ballad · mournful, bitter
- Rights status
- © David van Coolwijk / Boot Scoot Media. All rights reserved.
Or start a full listening session →
The other songs in this group
- Browse the full song catalogue →
- Read the story behind A Penny for a Sheet →
- Read the story behind Down by the Holston →
- Read the story behind It Was No Dream →
- Read the story behind John White Webster's Last →
- Read the story behind Remember Fifty-Eight →
- Read the story behind Seeing the Elephant →
- Read the story behind That's Why the Old Songs Run Sad →
- Read the story behind Turn the Leaders Wide →
- Read the story behind No More Singin' the Blues →
- Read the story behind Old Enough to Die →
- Read the story behind The Midnight Local →
- Read the story behind Bloodroot →
- Read the story behind Loyston Sea →
- Read the story behind More Than What You See →
- Read the story behind Wide as the Prairie Sky →
- Read the story behind Man at the Pot →
- Read the story behind Brown Mountain →
- Read the story behind All Hat Till the Branding →
- Read the story behind I Followed Work Around →
- Read the story behind Cowboys And Sad Songs →
- Read the story behind Nora's Ring →
- Read the story behind Ten Years for Sixty Seconds →
- Read the story behind Twenty Six Inches →
- Read the story behind Ropin Clouds →
- Read the story behind Page Six →
- Read the story behind Bad Ideas →
- Read the story behind Drinks on Me (Down at Joes) →
- Read the story behind The Last Gather →
- Read the story behind Wildwood Flower →