original song · Loyston, Tennessee, 1936

Loyston Sea

Appalachian · appalachian · mournful, bitter

▶ Play Loyston Sea

Loyston was a real town on the Clinch River, and the water over it really is called the Loyston Sea. The family in the song is invented; what happened to the town is not.

The story behind the song

Loyston sat in Union County, Tennessee, where Mill Creek runs into the Clinch River. It took its name from John Loy, who set up an iron foundry there early in the nineteenth century; the post office opened as Loy’s Cross Roads in 1866 and became Loyston in 1894. By 1935 about seventy people lived there. It had two general stores, a post office, a filling station, a café, a mill, a barbershop and an elementary school, and just outside town stood Sharps Station Methodist Episcopal Church. Lewis Hine photographed it for the Tennessee Valley Authority before it went; his caption on the church reads “This church will be submerged by the waters of the Norris Dam reservoir.”

Norris was the TVA’s first dam. Construction began in October 1933 and the gates closed on 4 March 1936, which is the “thirty-six” the first line counts to. Loyston, some twenty miles upstream, went under entirely. Across the whole reservoir about 2,800 families were moved out and more than 5,000 graves were dug up and reburied, most of them in four new cemeteries the TVA laid out for the purpose, one of them New Loyston Memorial in Union County. Families had to be gone between the fall harvest and spring planting; one of them, the Albrights, moved into a one-room temporary house on Christmas Day 1935. Most of Loyston’s people stayed in the hills nearby, some in a New Loyston a few miles south, others in Knox, Anderson, Blount and Loudon counties.

The name in the title is real. The flooded stretch, a mile-wide inlet of Norris Lake along the shore of Big Ridge State Park, is still called the Loyston Sea, and today it is used for boating and water-skiing. People from the old communities still keep up their cemeteries and gather at them on Decoration Day, the day each year when rural Southern families come together at the graves. The song’s chorus holds both of those at once: the place on the map, and the claim that “calling it home once” is all that is left.

What the record says, and what the song adds

The family is invented: the grandmother, the mother who was nine, the father’s hat, the Bible with Loyston crossed out. So is the order of events in the first verse. I found no record of the school letting out early, of when Loyston’s mill stopped, or of families being given six weeks to move their goods and two to move the dead; what the sources describe is a move that stretched over the winter of 1935–36. Nor did I find a depth for the town site, so “forty feet” is the song’s figure, not a measured one.

Three names lean on real ones without being them. Loyston was named for John Loy’s foundry; the stores I can name belonged to other families, so “Loy’s store” is the song’s. There is no “Baker’s Ridge” among the TVA reburial cemeteries: there is a Baker’s Forge Memorial, in Campbell County, and Loyston’s own was New Loyston Memorial. And I found no source that ties Norris’s first power to Knoxville in particular; it is the nearest city and a fair shorthand, but the record I read does not say it.

The bell under the water has no Loyston source either. It is one of the oldest legends there is, a church bell still heard ringing from a drowned village, collected across England and elsewhere for centuries. The song knows that: “I don’t know if that’s true, or just a story we tell each other.” And the gathering is real, but the sources call it Decoration Day, not a date in August.

Sources

Lyrics

Grandma said the mill wheel turned right up till thirty-six, said the schoolhouse let out early the week the men came through. She walked past Loy's store for a nickel's worth of candy, never dreamed that road would end up forty feet down. They gave her family six weeks to move the furniture and the stock, didn't give but two to move the dead. Loyston's down there under the Loyston Sea, forty feet of water where the front porch used to be. They call it progress, call it power for Knoxville, we call it the place we can't go home to. Loyston Sea, Loyston Sea, still current running under everything we are. Mama was nine when they rowed out past where the church used to stand, said Daddy dropped his hat in and never said a word. We moved the graves to Baker's Ridge, marked each one careful as we could, some stones so old the names had already worn away. I've got Great-Grandpa's Bible with the family names still in it, water-stained on the page where Loyston's crossed clean out. Loyston's down there under the Loyston Sea, forty feet of water where the front porch used to be. They call it progress, call it power for Knoxville, we call it the place we can't go home to. Loyston Sea, Loyston Sea, still current running under everything we are. Some folks say on a still night you can hear the old bell ringing I don't know if that's true, or just a story we tell each other Either way we still come out here every August And we still sing like somebody's listening under there Loyston's down there under the Loyston Sea, we can't drain it back, and we've made our peace with that. They call it progress, we still call it home once, and calling it that is the only claim we've got left. Loyston Sea, Loyston Sea, still current running under everything we are.

Lyrics by David van Coolwijk. The voice and the music are generated with AI (Suno). Printed here as written, without the production notes that appear in the player’s lyric sheet.

Credits

Lyrics
David van Coolwijk (captainfrasca)
Vocal
AI-generated
Voice
Eliza Lou Charlotte
Music
Generated with AI (Suno)
In the catalogue
Appalachian · appalachian · mournful, bitter
Rights status
© David van Coolwijk / Boot Scoot Media. All rights reserved.

Or start a full listening session →

The other songs in this group