Of all the songs with a page here, this is the one that holds up best against the documents. Nearly every checkable thing in it checks — including the family, and the dates.
The story behind the song
“Seeing the elephant” was the overlanders’ own phrase for the whole experience of the crossing. At the start it meant eager anticipation — John Clark wrote in 1852: “All hands early up anxious to see the path that leads to the Elephant.” By the far end of the trail the same phrase had curdled. Emigrants used it for the bad weather, the river crossings, the accidents and the deaths, and the elephant became the thing they blamed. The song takes the phrase at the moment it turns.
1852 was the worst of it. One study counts 2,800 deaths on the overland trail that year, against 2,100 in 1850 — the two peak cholera seasons along the Platte, out of migrations of about 70,000 and 52,000 people. Cholera killed fast: the pattern was “sick in the morning, dead at night.” It travelled in water fouled by the trains ahead, and nobody understood that yet; John Snow’s proof was still two years away. Emigrants who survived the first day usually recovered.
The Freels are real, and the song has them right. A letter written on 23 June 1852 at Ash Hollow by George and Ann Kiser lists the deaths in their party: Francis Freel on 4 June, Maria Freel on the 6th, Polly Casner on the 8th, Amos Freel on the 9th, LaFayette Freel on the 10th, Elizabeth — the wife of Amos — on the 11th, and her baby on the 17th. Seven, inside a fortnight. “All died of Cholera,” the letter says, and it blames the water from springs and sunken wells along the road, advising whoever reads it to drink from the Platte instead.
The fourth verse is right too, and it is the part most people get wrong. Of the deaths on the overland trails, roughly nine in ten were from disease. In the whole period of the migration, 362 emigrants and 426 Native people died in clashes between them — fewer emigrants, in twenty years of trail, than cholera took in a single bad week on the Platte. The National Park Service puts it plainly: tales of hostile encounters “far overshadowed actual incidents.”
And the fifth verse is a documented practice. The Park Service: “Single graves were often dug in the trail itself where the loose dirt could be compacted by the wagons that rolled over it,” and “most graves were deliberately left unmarked.” Trampled ground helped keep animals from digging up a shallow grave; Ezra Meeker recorded that many graves were levelled by hooves anyway, or opened by wolves.
What the record says, and what the song adds
Two small things the sources do not carry. The skull: writing messages on bone is documented — “beyond the Missouri River, the pioneers occasionally wrote messages on animal skulls and scapula,” with a surviving example from Thomas Bullock dated 8 June 1847. But the examples that survive are camp reports, not scripture, and the sources say “animal skulls” rather than buffalo. The scripture is the song’s. And the three hundred wagons of the first verse are scene, not record; the Kiser letter is about one party, not a train of that size.
Everything else held up. The family, the names, the dates, the count of seven, the cause, the water, the ratio of fever to arrow, the graves in the ruts, the absence of a stone. That is rare, and it is worth saying as plainly as the corrections.
Sources
- Freel Family — Oregon-California Trails Association
- Death and Danger on the Emigrant Trails — National Park Service
- Emigrants and Death along the Overland Trail (K.C. Clay) — NPS History
- Seeing the elephant — Wikipedia
- Cholera on the Oregon Trail — OldWest.org
- Mormon Pioneer National Historic Trail, Historic Resource Study, ch. 2 — NPS History
Lyrics
Lyrics by David van Coolwijk. Sung with an AI voice model based on his own voice; the music is made with AI (Suno). Printed here as written, without the production notes that appear in the player’s lyric sheet.
Credits
- Lyrics
- David van Coolwijk (captainfrasca)
- Vocal
- AI voice model based on David’s own voice
- Music
- Made with AI (Suno); the melody is sometimes David’s own
- In the catalogue
- Country · old-time · mournful, weary
- Rights status
- © David van Coolwijk / Boot Scoot Media. All rights reserved.
Or start a full listening session →
The other songs in this group
- Browse the full song catalogue →
- Read the story behind A Penny for a Sheet →
- Read the story behind Down by the Holston →
- Read the story behind It Was No Dream →
- Read the story behind John White Webster's Last →
- Read the story behind Mind the Cup →
- Read the story behind Remember Fifty-Eight →
- Read the story behind That's Why the Old Songs Run Sad →
- Read the story behind Turn the Leaders Wide →
- Read the story behind No More Singin' the Blues →
- Read the story behind Old Enough to Die →
- Read the story behind The Midnight Local →
- Read the story behind Bloodroot →
- Read the story behind Loyston Sea →
- Read the story behind More Than What You See →
- Read the story behind Wide as the Prairie Sky →
- Read the story behind Man at the Pot →
- Read the story behind Brown Mountain →
- Read the story behind All Hat Till the Branding →
- Read the story behind I Followed Work Around →
- Read the story behind Cowboys And Sad Songs →
- Read the story behind Nora's Ring →
- Read the story behind Ten Years for Sixty Seconds →
- Read the story behind Twenty Six Inches →
- Read the story behind Ropin Clouds →
- Read the story behind Page Six →
- Read the story behind Bad Ideas →
- Read the story behind Drinks on Me (Down at Joes) →
- Read the story behind The Last Gather →
- Read the story behind Wildwood Flower →